Script

Zero defect a Myth or a reality - Organization accountability


In a normal situation, consumers only buy one product and thus the product must be functioning for its intended usage and specification.  This means a product or service supplier to end consumer only get one chance to show their product is of good quality.  Therefore, all products sold to the consumer market should achieve zero-defect or a very low defect rate such as six sigma quality which is equal to 3.4 defects in one million parts.  

Product with zero defects is a dream of every organization.  The next big question would be what it takes to achieve zero defects.  In the modern world, the end product which reaches the end-user or consumer goes through a very long supply chain, from mother nature raw material such metal, silicon wafer, petrol chemical by-product to form into piece part assemble into sub-assembly and then join together to become final assembly. 



All the touchpoint throughout the supply chain will increase error opportunity which could induce defect in a product.  Refer to this link on the concept of the supply chain. 

The most important condition to strive for the perfection of zero defect is an overall product design with design for manufacturability, serviceability, consumer etc in mind.  Quality awareness must start right from the design of the product. 

Unfortunately, most of the design only focuses on the functionality of the product which resulted in poor manufacturability, the limited supply chain of material and complicated product which is not user friendly.
Many organizations did not realize that zero-defect must be designed in from raw material to piece part to sub-assembly to final assembly.  The irony is that those organizations thought manufacturing process can compensate for the poor design and limited material supply base. 

Very often a company tend to take short cut design process of a product to save on design cost and time to market which uses substandard material.  This had created a ripple effect where company have to live with poor design, spend a huge amount of money to hire resources downstream to manage complicated manufacturing process for the infinite duration of time. 

I will share more about design for manufacturability concept which leads to the zero-defect product in the next article. Please do follow this website by clicking on "Follow" on the top right sidebar.   I have created a youtube video to explain more on this topic.






What is the difference between lean and six sigma - Part 1

When I started my career in the electronics manufacturing during early 90s, six sigma was prevalent where every company wanted to achieve 6 sigma qualities at that time.  According to Wikipedia, six sigma approach was pioneered by Motorola engineers in 80s for the purpose of process improvement.  This methodology focus on data collection and statistical analysis of data, using quality tools for root cause identification and action plan to address the root cause thru phase by phase approach.  It is then follow data analysis using statistic to verify if there is significant follow by standardize action plan to sustain the improvement.  It had become a big phenomenon when Jack Welch made six sigma GE business strategy in 1995.  Several American based multinational corporations followed suit and claimed to have huge saving therefore they are making profit and in business the biggest incentive is profit $.  The word is six sigma  became catch phrase for most company top management,  therefore they “force” their organization to establish six sigma projects everywhere irrespective if  it is a suitable approach or not.

When we approach the 21st century, lean concept practice by Toyota caught the attention of the western world when Dr. Womack et al.  release an iconic book about lean (The Machine That Changed the World) in the 90s.  This book was based on their research in MIT about innovative management and production system use in Toyota.  As lean tools are quite simple and easy to adopt, a lot of company start to use the popular tools such as 5s, standard work, poke-yoke (error proof), kaizen etc., with almost immediate results seen. Thus lean slowly take over six sigma as the groundbreaking tool in production and management.

By the time lean become popular, many organizations had already adopted six sigma “culture” religiously.  At the same time most management does not want to lose out to company who embraced lean which had gain a block buster results,  they start to assimilate lean tools and thus the beginning of term lean six sigma.  Most of the training companies start to rid the wave of trend by offering Lean six sigma course.  
Lean six sigma is a very misguided term as both lean and six sigma are entirely different.  Lean is a culture and six sigma is an approach to reduce variation contributed by poor process control.    Six sigma could be part of lean and not vice versa. 
Six sigma is a structured variation reduction methodology.  I found that a lot of engineers who had study or deploy six sigma still do NOT understand the real meaning of variation reduction.  I would like to use the scenario below to illustrate the meaning of variation reduction.    A manufacturing company found that their product could not customer specification for length of 308.50+/-0.30 (308.20-308.80).  Base on the data collected for product length and plotted on the control chart on the left, it seems some data already exceed or below spec.  The company had to reject the product which does mean customer spec.  The quality engineer decided to use six sigma approach to improve the process in order to produce parts which consistently meet customer spec.  After improvement, the quality engineer collect the product length data and plot in control chart (right).  It was found the product length variation had reduced with tighter control limit as compare to the chart on the left.  It also show that the product length can consistently meet customer spec,  Thus variation of the product length had reduced using six sigma approach.


Six sigma phase by phase approach from define, measure, analyze, improve and control is to ensure that variation quality characteristic of the product is reduce or bring to target per customer spec or both.

Six sigma will only meaningful in a process improvement if useful data are collected diligently with big enough sample size to study the current trend and make a statistical conclusion on the population behavior.  Data collection could focus on one or at the most two parameters which are critical to quality identified through mapping customer requirement.  After improvement, data is collected again and analyzed statistically to ensure the trend had improved for overall population.  Therefore it is very statistical based tactical tools to achieve customer requirement be on objective specification of certain critical quality metric and we must be able to measure the quality metric.

Do refer to this video for more details


Proactive leadership in Quality management

 


Saying no to such work pattern requires a lot of leadership, planning, courage and communications. 

Sometimes we are overwhelmed with so many issues that we are lost and unable to lead ourselves out of those situations. Therefore we continued to firefight for the rest of our working lives and hated our work.

The situation is aggravated if you working for management does not have a clear understanding of what is going on and no objective how to minimize even prevent problems.

 We must treat all problems as our enemy,  lead ourselves and our team to go to war to conquer this enemy.

Know yourself well, know your enemy even better, a hundred battles fought a hundred battles win. 

This is a famous quote by Sun Tzu, a military strategist found in the Art of War, an ancient Chinese military treatise.  It starts with taking the lead to understand the problem very well, such as asking questions of what, where, when, who and how and gathering accurate data.  This seems to be a simple step; however, many had failed due to lack of knowledge and perspective to look at the problem differently.  Once the problem is well defined,  we should have some insights if the problem is within our capability to solve or there is no immediate solution.   Learn to acknowledge that the problem cannot be prevented with current resources is essential for us to manage the problem.

This is where the problem gets bigger as everyone is only thinking of solving it instead of managing it.  I will discuss more about it in the future.

Once you know the problem, then planning is needed to establish a solution to prevent or manage the problem.  A problem that is well defined will make planning for action is more straightforward.   This will require knowledge gain from learning and experience.  Our knowledge is will help us to search for the eureka moment in planning for a solution.  We must have the courage to plan for a solution which could go beyond the four walls of the manufacturing facility.  

Improvement in minimizing or prevent problem will not happen by just planning.  We need to put the problem and action plan into the right perspective so that we can communicate clearly to the management and team member.

Communication to the management is very important to influence the management to support and invest in resources to make the plan into reality. 

We must eliminate the victim’s mentality and be proactive in leading ourselves towards a better work-life as the first step towards in being control.  If you are in a leadership position, ensure that you are part of the solution to the problem.








Supplier Quality Management Course @ Udemy

 For those who seek or want to advance their #career in #supplier #quality #management, Would like to share this  course on seven essentials on supplier quality management  in Udemy .   I have put in more than 20 years of knowledge and experience into creating this course. I am an authority in this area where I have wrote books on this subject.

This course will help to prepare for interview which you will outshine your competitor supplier quality manager or engineer post.

You will have life access to this course where you can take your time to finish the course. This is an investment you must make to get ahead in your career as supplier quality management professional. 

Click on the image below or scan the QR code to find out more details

#career #interview #supplier #quality #management 






 

Which quality cost should be the primary focus of your company? Part 1



A few weeks ago I had run a poll in linkedin group 360 Proactive Quality Engineering  to find out which quality cost get the least attention from quality engineering practitioner.   (please refer to embedded link on quality cost to learn more on quality cost)  79% had  selected prevention cost follow by appraisal and internal cost  which reflects the actual situation in the industry.  

Most companies had failed to look into #prevention cost due to quality problem is seldom a pain point during the development stage as the biggest challenge to launch a new product would be time to market.  The development and marketing team would prefer less interaction with other groups to shorten the design cycle, and less work involves to plan in quality in this silo over the wall approach where I design it and you build it.  Sad to say this is still practice in some company till today.   Typically, the quality problem will only show up during mass production or worst during customer integration.  Every organization who are serious about their profitability should understand the cost of correcting a problem at the customer end is more than thousands times more than rectifying problem during design stage.  The table below an example of how quality cost grows in the different product life cycle.  Therefore, preventive cost should be the primary focus, especially product with the short product life as product development happens almost every quarter.  These types of companies should adopt advance quality planning approach to plan quality into every stage of product life.  All quality #engineers should show this table to your management if quality planning is not yet the primary focus of the company.  This is also the best proactive approach to adopt.  

 

Product Life

 Cost of correcting problem

Design phase

$ 35

Before buying the parts

$177

Before start of mass production

$368

During Mass production

$5900

After shipped to customers

$590000 (many parts could have shipped)

 

In my next article,  I shall share on which cost should be a primary focus where in situation that prevention cost cannot be the primary focus anymore.


Channel Evelyn7E premiere – appreciate the support to subscribe



New YouTube channel Evelyn7E premiere today on 7 Dec 2020 especially created for process, quality & management professional.   I will share 30 years of my engineering and management experience on hacking into key areas to achieve good results proactively  in  this channel.  There will be video on application quality and management tools and some insights on what to control in specific manufacturing process such as PCBA,  mechanical assembly to get stable product.  Scan the QR code or click on the video below to go to my channel and subscribe to my channel.  Appreciate the  sharing with all who can benefit from this channel.   


#quality
 #management #sharepost #engineering


Thank You





2020 World Quality Day - Creating Customer Value

 

World quality day which falls on the second Thursday of Nov was created by the Chartered Quality Institute (CQI) since 1990.  This special day was established to bring the awareness and recognition of the quality professionals contribution in delivering quality products to the world.   Quality professionals are committed not only in customer quality but also safety in most of the organizations.  Many companies around the world will celebrate this momentous occasion in Nov every year.  This year theme is creating value to the customer.

Customers are getting more sophisticated over time with upgraded needs & wants, and their voice can be heard over social media.  A delighter attribute today might be a must-have in the future according to Kano analysis model on product feature.  Every organization should involve quality engineering professional right from the start of product design to ensure quality is plan into the product through the rigour of using the correct quality tools such as kano analysis, quality function deployment and advance product quality plan.  A capable quality professional must ensure that the quality voice is heard throughout the organization and drive all functions put in effort in achieving quality at a minimal cost.  In my previous LinkedIn article, I have mentioned that quality problem is always hidden and it takes a lot of resources to rectify a problem at customer end.

The customer wants, and needs can evolve, however, one thing that never changes is the customer always require a product which works well to solve their pain point at the lowest cost possible.

Creating value to the customer also this is one of the foundations in lean.  This is translated into producing consistently good quality, a defect-free product with minimal quality cost and waste. 

May Quality professionals be inspired to create customer value by ensuring quality and safety design into the product and achieve a balance in the voice of the business, the voice of the process and voice of the customer. 

Note:  CQI and IRCA had prepare an excellent resources to celebrate world quality day @  https://www.quality.org/wqd20-toolkit




The hidden rainbow in 7 manufacturing process inputs - how to find it

Did you know that even if a product is well designed, there are numerous factors that can cause variations in each process input? It's like a Pandora's box of potential problems waiting to be unleashed! The table below provides a glimpse into some of these issues, but trust me, it's just the tip of the iceberg. There could be even more lurking beneath the surface.


Process input

Potential source of variation

Man

Emotion, absent from work, fatigue, no proper training process

Machine

Wear and tear, natural shift or drift of machine

Method

No written work instruction, unclear work instruction, complicated work instruction

Material

Material from multiple suppliers, not able to control supplier process input

Measure

Measure process not set up properly, operator not train to measurement, natural shift of measuring equipment

Environment

Product sensitive to changes in temperature and not proper control in place


Are you aware that one misstep during the setup of a manufacturing process can have disastrous consequences for the final product? Imagine all your hard work ending up as a rejected item at the customer's doorstep. That's a nightmare no one wants to experience! 

But fear not, because there's a solution. By taking a proactive approach and meticulously setting up and controlling each process input, you can minimize the risk of encountering quality issues in your end product. And that's not all – monitoring the process output effectively can provide early warnings, giving you the opportunity to address any potential problems before they escalate.

Exciting news awaits! I've prepared a comprehensive blueprint that focuses on process inputs. It's a treasure map, leading you to uncover the hidden rainbow that will guide you straight to your pot of gold – a flawless manufacturing process. And guess what? I want to share this valuable resource with all of you on this website.

Ready to unlock the secrets to manufacturing success? All you need to do is fill in your details in the form below to receive this extraordinary gift absolutely free. Get ready to embark on an exhilarating journey towards manufacturing excellence!






The hidden rainbow in 7 manufacturing process inputs


The manufacturing process is a series of work which transform materials in a repetitive large-scale environment to a finished product that customer is willing to pay for.   All man-made product we use every day from the simplest product such as a toothbrush to a sophisticated high technology product will go through many manufacturing processes in multiple factories.  Multiple manufacturing entities, together with transportation and logistic form a long supply chain. 

A process must consist of a series of actions that transform process input into the process output per figure below:- 


Figure 1. Process input vs process output


The process output can be, in turn, become a process input in the subsequent process. Typical manufacturing process inputs are materials, man, methods, machine, measure and environment known as 5Ms and 1E.  Product design is one more process input which will impact the process output. The process output can be, in turn, become a process input in the subsequent process.

Each process input must be set up and control properly to achieve the desired process output either as a finished good or a process input to a subsequent process. Remember garbage in garbage out.  An end consumer product could go through hundreds if not thousands of transformation process per figure below from one manufacturing entity to another per the figure above.   A product which had gone through 100  transformation processes with seven process input would have 700 opportunities for error which impact the product quality.   There could be a potential of scrap or rework cost, which of quality cost if the process input is not setup correctly.

Even a simple toothbrush will consist of multi-tier supplier’s product transformation.

Therefore setting up process input properly is critical to all production process.  The next question is, what does it take to set up the manufacturing process inputs correctly to get to the end of the rainbow🌈 .  More in the next article.


Book Release with two free gifts : -7 Essentials in Supplier Quality Management

Click on the photo below!!👇

I have decided to start my first book base on my subject matter of expertise in supplier quality management.  Two decades of my experience in systematically managing supplier quality to achieve consistently good quality products is shared in this book.

Company success relies heavily on the quality of material received from the supplier along the supply chain. Many organizations had been struggling with low-quality incoming part from suppliers and pay way above the actual material cost to manage those inferior quality parts.   Imagine an organization have a customer who is ready to buy the product; however, there is no material to transform the product into sales. Almost all supplier delivery problem is associated with the supplier having quality issues which had caused limited supply or inferior quality product. It is nearly impossible to turn defective materials into good quality products.  

Organizations are paying way above the actual material cost due to poor quality as additional cost are incurred in the following areas:-

  1.  Defective material inventory cost
  2.  Transportation of poor quality material
  3.  Storage space to store poor quality material
  4.  Hire more workers to screen inferior quality parts
  5.  Compensation cost to customer due to late delivery

This book focuses on a systematic approach in 7 essentials of area supplier quality to achieve defect-free product from supplier process. This single system would help to reduce variation in managing different suppliers which also leads to consistent results.  In turn, this will enable an organization to receive consistent good quality part to feed the manufacturing process can convert the product into sales and revenue. There are a total of 16 figures and five tables to summarize a large amount of information which enhance the reading experience of this book.   This book is written by a supplier quality practitioner like me for a supplier quality practitioner. 

Two exclusive gifts are included on

  • Guide on how to build a supplier audit checklist and
  • Excel format sample checklist.  The reader can directly use the excel checklist to create final quality audit checklist. 

Finally appreciate the support for this book from audiences in this website.  

The book is available through this link:.  You can also click on the photo above to get the link.

https://www.amazon.com/author/evelyntan


Is Quality free - Do not shed a tear until they see the coffin

In my previous article,  we already know the 3 main reasons why quality is not free which are all related to design.

In the past most of the manufacturing processes are very much dependant on human where most of the defect have direct cause are human error, therefore emphasis on “do it right the first time” was focused on the manufacturing process.

If a further root cause analysis is done,  the final cause is actually due to design per the example below. 

A simple example would be doing a 5 why analysis



From the figure above,  it seems that the manufacturing cause is the cause of the component damage when we deep dive the root cause is pointed to the design issue where the component is designed too near to the edge of the board and cause handling damage.

This will increase the cost of manufacturing due to extra control, rework, more inspection and risk of shipping defect to customer. 

We can move towards quality is free by understanding how to prevent or minimize the  4 types of quality cost

Category 

Description

Suggested Mitigation  Plan

Appraisal cost

Cost of performing test and inspection on a product to screen out potential defect include inspector.

·       Create testing which replicate customer environment

 

Internal failure cost

Cost of rework or scrapped product which does not comply to the spec

·       Product design that are error proof

 

External failure cost

Cost of poor quality at customer site which involve warranty cost, product recall, lost of customer trust

·       Plan in quality per prevention cost plan, then quality is really free

 

Prevention cost

Cost of preventing a defect through quality planning of design in quality and build in quality

·       Ensure quality function gets involved during the early design stage

·       Benchmark on predecessor product if any to correct the problem

·       Proper FMEA involve all downstream function such as production and customer quality

·       Study how product being used in customer environment and design the part for customer convenience

 


From the table above,  it is shown that by focusing on preventive cost through proper quality planning would have minimized the appraisal cost and even eliminate failure cost.  Bear in mind quality issues design stage will on 1/1000 of the failure cost at the customer site.

Unfortunately, many organizations choose not to put in effort in quality planning during the design stage and hope the problem will never surface during manufacturing or customer site.   The management mindset does not shed a tear until they see the coffin (不見棺材不落淚 ) had caused them to pay for enormous quality cost especially if failure happens at customer integration. 


Sharing is caring

Continuous Improvement Program CIP - 6sigma Methodology